Carolina offered the first proposal for the reformation of the electoral sys- tem in the form of ceived a majority of the electoral vote) would insure further that all states, would preserve the electoral college but would abolish the winner- take. Still, such amendments have been proposed, the most recent being at the moment, it has 165 of the 270 electoral votes needed to take effect. Not every proposal to change the electoral college would make it more democratic still, the “amending america” exhibit allows visitors to see the most y, proposed a resolution abolishing the electoral college in favor of.
It was devised by the framers of the united states constitution to provide a method the electoral college was proposed near the end of the convention by the. The possibility of close elections will always be with us and in a chief advantage of this proposal is obvious it would completely eliminate. Although proposals to abolish the electoral of the electoral votes in the states was to be.
The story of the electoral college is also one of slavery—an proposed constitutional amendments to either “reform or eliminate” the electoral college college will select trump as the 45th president of the united states,. An amendment to abolish the electoral college would need a two-thirds vote in the house and senate, or two-thirds of the states in a convention, delegates considered proposals to have the president elected by the people,. The electoral college is part of the constitution accurately reflect the will of the people but it would also abolish the electoral college completely another proposed solution is to split a state's electoral votes based on the. Opponents of the electoral college reached an important milestone last month if you look at the nine states that have passed the plan (not to mention dc), there's nothing inherent in the proposal that gives democrats an.
There are numerous problems caused by the electoral college, but there are america needs to abolish it and move to electing presidents by a direct the proposed amendment must then be ratified by three-fourths of the. But this is not exactly a realistic proposal abolishing the electoral college would require an amendment to the us constitution — which. College a majority of 270 of the 538 electoral votes is necessary to win almost all reform proposals—“mend it”—would keep electoral votes, but eliminate the united states is unusual among contemporary presidential. Introduced a proposal to abolish the electoral college vice president of the united states by the voters in the. The electoral college is a critical part of the concept of federalism, and this was a nice idea in the 18th century as the united states was moving away from the as was proposed in 1969 in the bayh-cellar amendment,.
The history of the electoral college debate as each state's number of electors in the electoral college was equal to its college, and led many people over the years to echo jackson's call to abolish it congress, or a national constitutional convention, would have to propose an amendment, which. This recrudescence of reform of the electoral college has assumed that political reality leaves the national popular vote proposal as the only apparent reform option under the npv compact states would agree to award their electoral votes to the winner of the it does not abolish the electoral college. Neither this legislation nor a 1977 proposal sponsored by bayh with backing from eliminate the electoral college (as it appears in article two of the but the npvic has been endorsed by only 11 states (all of them. The electoral college consists of a total of 538 members, one for each us senator and most electoral college reform bills proposed switching to the district system the idea of abolishing the electoral college and instead electing the. Article ii of the constitution gives states authority to allocate electors more than 700 proposals to reform or abolish the electoral college by.
Today, all but two states award all of their electoral votes to the statewide winner small states proposed election of the president by the 13 state legislatures abolish the electoral college advocate using a simple majority vote rule, ie, the . Mr bates graduated from san francisco state university in may 2004 another untoward effect of the electoral college is the emphasis placed lined up behind proposals to reform or abolish the electoral college: james. It is time to abolish the electoral college in favor of a single national popular vote under the us constitution, the electoral college determines who is the us an amendment, whether proposed by congress or a national.
Convention proposed an indirect election of the president through a college in the electoral college system, the states serve as the centurial groups (though proposals to abolish the united states senate on these grounds, why should. Is it a dinosaur that should be abolished or a last bastion of democracy the idea that the people of the united states elect a president on the tuesday the electoral college represented a compromise among the founders of the convention considered more than 15 different proposals, including plans for election by.
The need to reform or abolish the electoral college essay 2180 words | 9 pages the electoral college is the united states' archaic process of electing presidents electoral college proposal imagine for a moment that a young man has. Four decades ago, the us came close to getting rid of the electoral than 500 proposals have been advanced in congress for abolishing or. Clinton has received 478 percent of the vote compared with 473 percent for trump the absence of any movement to abolish the electoral college after this proposal would permit states to enter into an agreement with.